When Can You Sue After a New York Car Crash?
New York law limits pain and suffering claims in car accidents to serious injuries, requiring medical evidence to meet statutory thresholds before compensation is awarded.

A crash on the LIE near Jericho usually starts with a no-fault claim, not a lawsuit. In New York, one covered person is not allowed to recover pain and suffering from another covered person unless that injury is a “serious injury,” and basic economic loss is also off the table in that suit. The lawsuit threshold is a legal category, not a medical adjective.
Those limits are in Insurance Law section 5104(a). This article covers the serious-injury list, basic economic loss, and the fault-first sequence in 5104(a). If you were hurt in Nassau County, the first question is whether the injury meets one of the statutory categories, not only how painful the week after the crash felt.
Who is barred from a pain-and-suffering suit?
Section 5104(a) covers a suit by, or for, a covered person who sues another covered person over personal injuries that grew out of negligent driving or use of a vehicle in this state. In that setting, pain-and-suffering recovery is closed unless the injury is a serious injury, and first-party economic loss cannot be recovered in that suit either. Section 5102(c) treats non-economic loss as pain and suffering and comparable harms that are not measured in dollars. A finding of liability for that kind of harm waits until the fact-finder has first decided that a serious injury exists. In a suit under this article for that kind of harm, the fact-finder is not allowed to decide whether the injury is serious until it has already decided who was at fault.
That sequence is easy to miss in an early demand. A discussion with a Friedman & Simon car accident lawyer in Jericho is about whether the record supports a statutory serious-injury category, not about a general claim that every painful crash belongs in court. The medical records have to match a 5102(d) category.
Which injuries meet the statutory list
Section 5102(d) now looks at what the injury produced: death, loss of a limb, a marked and lasting change in appearance, a broken bone, or fetal loss. It also covers three impairment paths: a lasting total loss of use of an organ, limb, function, or system; a lasting, consequential restriction on how an organ or limb works; and a significant restriction on how a function or system works. The budget legislation enacted as Chapter 58 of 2026, Assembly 10008-C and Senate 9008-C, carries a signing date of May 26, 2026, and in Part EE the old 90/180-day non-permanent-injury category was removed for actions started from that date forward. A sprain that resolves, without a remaining category on that list, does not open a pain-and-suffering suit in a newly filed case, while a broken bone is enough on the face of the current statute.
What you still recover without a lawsuit
Section 5102(a) caps basic economic loss at $50,000 per person across a combined set of items. Those items include needed medical and hospital care, surgery, nursing, dental work, ambulance transport, imaging, prescriptions, and prosthetic care, plus certain therapy and other professional health services, with no time cap, so long as it is clear within a year of the crash that later bills may still come due. Lost earnings are included, at up to $2,000 a month, for no more than three years after the crash. Other reasonable, necessary costs are included at up to $25 a day for no more than a year. Under 5102(b), first-party benefits repay basic economic loss after a 20 percent reduction of lost earnings and after certain collateral sources are subtracted.
When a motorcycle or a non-covered person is involved
Section 5104(a) also says that a motorcycle owner, rider, or passenger who carries the required financial security is not open to a covered person’s suit for pain and suffering, unless the injury is a serious injury, and is not open to a suit for first-party economic loss either. Section 5104(b) addresses a suit against a non-covered person: the no-fault insurer holds a lien on any recovery up to the benefits it paid or still owes, and a settlement generally needs the insurer’s written consent, court approval, or a settlement above $50,000. If the covered person does not start that action within two years after it accrues, the insurer may bring its own claim for benefits paid or still owed.
What to gather in Jericho
Start with the police report, the NF-2 or other no-fault filings, and imaging or operative reports that show a broken bone, a documented restriction, or another 5102(d) category. A guide to the complexities of a personal injury claim is useful once you have that list, because the threshold question comes before a damages number. Compare the records to section 5102(d) as it stands.











